4.5 out of 5 stars and 66 reviews
4.5
(66)Best of Weddings (1x).46-24 28th street, Long Island City, NY
About this vendor
With Clarity is the only online, direct to consumer home try-on engagement ring company that marries affordability with expertise and convenience with a personal touch. Because getting engaged is exceptional, how you shop for a ring should be too. We craft all jewelry in-house with purity, quality, and authenticity.
With our Free Home Preview, you can try replicas of your favorite engagement ring styles at home to make a confident decision. Then return to our site to fully customize your ring and make it one of a kind. We have the lowest diamond prices guaranteed and a refreshing new way to shop for engagement rings.
Rings you can browse online and try at home. Jewelry that would add sparkle to your everyday.
Free Home Preview, Free Engraving, Free Resizing, Conflict-Free Diamonds.
With Clarity was formerly Four Mine.
Details
Business Attributes
- Asian-owned Business
- Woman-owned Business
Rings
- Engagement Rings
- Ring Services
- Appraisals
- Custom Designs
- Engraving
- Financing Available
Wedding Jewelry
- Bracelets
- Earrings
- Necklaces
- Rings
Awards and Affiliations
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
4.5
out of 5.066 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 2
- Top reviews
- Newest first
- Oldest first
- Highest rated
- Lowest rated
Sort by
I had the absolute worst experience ordering my engagement ring through this company. The “ship by” date that I relied on when ordering turned out to be wrong, and I had to call in on a daily basis for updates and push them to “expedite” the “quality check” process in order to have them ship the ring, still later than what it was originally scheduled for. They didn’t even overnight the ring per my request to make up for their delay, and as a result, I had to push back the trip I had planned and proposal I spent months preparing for in order to wait on the ring to ship.
While I was pleased with the ring itself, the box had “With Clarity” largely and hideously emblazoned on the inside of the box, which frankly is gaudy and not ideal for opening the box to surprise your partner with.
Customer service, while friendly, seemed fairly incompetent throughout the entire ordeal, and it was one of the worst experiences I’ve ever had with this sort of process. With how important planning a once in lifetime event such as a proposal is, and with the amount of time, money, and emotion you’re investing, I recommend staying away from With Clarity and shopping elsewhere.
Terrible experience, took over a month past expected shipping date. Even had to push things back due to their screw up. I purchased a ring and diamond and 2 days later they emailed me saying the diamond I picked and already paid for wasn’t available, even though they “second check” when purchase. A load of BS. They said they couldn’t swap the diamond, even though I was picking same band and same shape diamond. I had to wait 2 weeks for my money to be refunded so I could order another. Over a month after receiving the ring and months after order date I have yet to receive my appraisal I paid extra money for.… still nothing, there seems to be a lack of care and communication. Never in my life did I imagine such a crappy experience buying an engagement ring, shouldn’t one actually look forward to that considering it is one of the biggest steps in life?
The ring looks nice but don’t buy it. To say I’m disappointment just doesn’t seem like enough. I purchased the Men's Bevel Edge Comfort Fit Band with a satin finish for my husband and it’s already scratched up, again. We got married on May 11th and after a few days of wearing it, it had a bunch of scratches on it. So With Clarity had me ship it back and the lady I spoke with said instead of just polishing it, they pretty much gave me a brand new ring. I get that ring back and it’s been a few weeks and it has scratches on it. I was concerned about that when I shipped it back to be repaired but the company said don’t worry about that and that if it does get scratch, they can polish it for $50. It’s crazy that after 2 months I would have had to pay $150 after purchasing the ring. They didn’t charge me for shipping it back the first time (which they shouldn’t have in the first place). After getting it back, my husband barely wears it. He has to wash his hands a lot (at a minimum after each patient) at work so instead of taking it on and off 20x a day, he doesn’t wear it. Same with exercising, when I spoke to the lady about the ring, she said he can’t wear it when exercising. So most of the time it’s either sitting on a counter or in the box. Since you only get 30 days to return or exchange, even if we picked it out a week before the wedding, we would have been stuck with it. $800 wasted. This isn’t like a special occasion type of ring, it’s an everyday ring and it can’t last a few weeks without getting messed up? I would have been better off going with some random company buying a cheaper ring. At least I wouldn’t feel so screwed. I decided to go with this company because it’s where my husband bought my engagement and wedding band. My ring is fine but overall, I don’t recommend this company based off the customer service, their policies and quality of wedding bands. Take your chance and go with someone else. I’m going to try and sell this one and use the money to buy a better quality ring with another company.
Great jewelry at a great price!
I was very pleasantly surprised at the quality of the diamond. The website is great and shows you your exact diamond (at least I think it does most of the time from what I saw). I was pretty skeptical, to say it lightly, until I talked to a family member that is a jeweler. He indicated the diamond was indeed real, was very good, and labeled appropriately. They said it would take about 15 business days to create the setting but they had it sent to me way, way ahead of time. I’m thrilled and I’ll be back if I have a need. I definitely recommend!!
Can’t recommend. My engagement ring from here (online order) was beautiful but within one year, we realized the stone was extremely loose. We took it to a jeweler and they said the setting was very poorly constructed and we’re glad we didn’t lose the stone. We had the jeweler fix it.
Shortly after this, my wedding ring, which I had been wearing for only a couple of weeks, had multiple diamonds fall out. Mind you, I only wear it for dressing up and never for anything that would cause damage to it. We contacted customer service, they repaired it after we paid to ship it back. This cycle has now been repeated FOUR TIMES. We continue to get a ring back that is poorly constructed and has diamonds falling out of it within a couple months. I imagine we’ll just continue to send it back every few months or so until the warranty ends. It’s so upsetting.
I would avoid this company if you value customer service! They do not make an effort to work with customers. I am not a gemologist, so I counted on their staff to help me make the right decision regarding my purchase. When the stone came, it was not the right size for the setting, so I returned it. I purchased another stone and it did not look very bright in the setting. They refused to exchange it because it would have been my second exchange. I offered to purchase another stone that was more expensive, but they said that was "unfair to other customers to allow me to make two exchanges". (Thank goodness other companies aren't as picky. One would think a diamond that has a serial number would be durable enough to be exchanged without harming the integrity of the stone.) I was finally told, "Try to sell the stone to a third party." So now I have a stone I don't like and I am purchasing from another company. If you value customer service, avoid them like the plague! And what is ironic is that they sent me an email offering me a $10 Amazon gift card if I completed this review. At least Amazon has good customer service. I have actually returned socks to Amazon, but With Clarity won't allow me to exchange an item more than once. Unless you are an experienced gemologist who knows how to buy a stone, don't use them.
I would not recommend the at home try on for a variety of reasons. Customer service & experience is critical to the success of a company in the engagement ring business. After my second try on, I sent my rings back with the label given by the company, & it didn't have shipment tracking. Because I had tried on a few, I was finally down to the last try on before purchase. Assuming my order made it back, I ordered my last round. A week later, I was contacted by a customer service rep who cancelled my order because of the policy violation of two outstanding orders at once. I respect policy, and in this case I legitimately did not mean to break it. The team did not work with me to fix my issue & was okay cancelling my business.
Options for keeping customers in the future:
o Work with the customer - Give them the delivery estimation from their previous order & offer shipment after that date.
o Find better customer service reps and focus on customer experience.
o Always assume good intentions. (EQ 101)
I'm really disappointed because this is where I wanted to buy my ring. I'll have to look elsewhere and start over.
Gorgeous diamonds, I love it so much I got a pendant as well! Amazing prices, beautiful quality, and great service all around.
I am over-the-moon in love with my ring from With Clarity. The diamond is absolutely gorgeous, and the gold band is even more beautiful that I expected it would be. They event customized the ring for me so that it would have clawed prongs, which I love. Thank you, With Clarity!
I was pointed to With Clarity from a friend who also bought from them for his fiancés engagement ring. It's so easy to customize exactly what you're looking for and finding a diamond within your price range is easy using their filtering tools. The ring I received was exactly what I was looking for! The support staff are very responsive and got the resizing taken care of quickly and without worry. I ended up buying the wedding band here as well. For the newer generation who like to shop online and avoid the salesmen, this is the perfect place to buy jewelry.
I got a diamond pendant from my boyfriend for Christmas. It’s so high quality and beautiful. I love how simple and elegant it is. It shines and glistens in every direction!
We had the best experience! We were a little skeptical ordering a ring online but after a lot of research we decided to try the at home trial from with clarity. We trialed several rings and finally found one that we loved. They were great to work with and answered all our questions and had a huge variety of diamonds. Overall I would recommend this to all my friends
My fiancé and I chose to design our ring on the With Clarity website and it turned out to be exactly what we wanted! You can pick the setting and stone you’d like and see a preview of it before ordering. They also have affordable jewelry like earrings and rings that are so nice as gifts.
The best! Easy stone selection and great settings. Saved me at least $1k-$2k!
Really easy to find exactly what we were looking for. I had a few questions and I was able to chat with the same online gemologist about two diamonds I was in between purchasing. She was honest and gave me good advice on which one to choose. We absolutely love the diamond that we chose and the process was super easy!
Great experience. Found them via Rarecarat. Support was quick to respond. Item arrived on time - even while there was a major snowstorm in the North East. I'll be ordering the wedding band soon.
Awesome quality at an amazing price, so glad I found Clarity!
Website is easy to navigate and compare rings. Ring came slightly different than pictured do to karats but we love it all the same.
got my diamonds from here and amazing deals. love how transparent they are
My diamond Exceeded more than my expectations.
Most jewelers will tell you your diamond is vVs1 but really si....NOPE not with clarity I been getting king treatment and pampered since I gave my fiance the ring!!!!!
Had to replace my lost engagement and wedding rings and came across With Clarity in my searches on Rare Carat. Ended up finding the most stunning oval diamond (E color, VVS2 clarity, excellent cut) on With Clarity's site for what seemed like a too good to be true price, and decided to give it a shot. So worth it! I ended up taking my ring to an independent appraiser in Seattle, WA to make sure the diamond I got is what I ordered - which it absolutely was and appears I did get a fantastic deal. Writing this review in case anyone else is a little unsure about purchasing a diamond online. Not only is the diamond absolutely stunning, the ring is so well crafted and exactly as described. All in all, I would recommend With Clarity to ANYONE who is ring shopping and wants to get the most diamond for their money. Jewelers and the big websites (Blue Nile, James Allen) prices for a comparable diamond and ring were SIGNIFICANTLY higher than what I paid at With Clarity (talking $8K-$10K higher!). I couldn't be happier with my purchase and will buy from With Clarity when I shop for my replacement wedding band.
Purchased a diamond engagement ring from With Clarity and it is perfect. My fiancée loves it! Customer service was excellent, with great straight-forward communication. Their pricing was very competitive and they had the perfect setting which was difficult to find. Delivery presentation was also lovely. Have since purchased the matching wedding band and, once again, With Clarity did not disappoint. I am now searching online for my wedding band and will not hesitate to purchase it from With Clarity if it should be the ring style of my choosing. I highly recommend this company.
I purchased a diamond/ring from With Clarity and ended up returning it for another ring - they handled the exchange professionally with good communication and instructions. Throughout the process they were responsive and the end product was excellent (and at an excellent price). Really impressed with this service.
I went into this expecting the most stressful experience of my life. With Clarity made everything so easy and the ring was the real deal. So awesome. Highly recommend.
I shopped way too long for a diamond engagement ring. I should have came to With Clarity way sooner. I maneuvered around the website with ease and was able to dial in exactly what I wanted. Prices are good, customer services was good- the ring was great!
Great experience using With Clarity. The ring looks just like the photos and they kept me in the loop while it was getting prepared and shipped. It would’ve been a 5 star review but I had a small issue when trying to insure the ring. Despite sending me the ring 3 weeks before I tried to insure it, I had to pay to have it appraised by With Clarity. Not sure why they didn’t appraise it while they had it, but I either had to ship it back for $40 or get an estimated appraisal for $60. Just doesn’t make a ton of sense to me. Seems like something that should be done prior to sending it to me.
Great place to shop. Loved my necklace
After extensive research and consideration with regard to finding an engagement ring for my now fiancée, I chose to go through With Clarity. Not only did they have an amazing selection of loose stones and settings, but their pricing was beyond compare. They were extremely helpful with answering all of my questions, and were very responsive when I decided to change the inscription on the setting the day after purchasing the ring. I could not have had a better experience and the ring is absolutely perfect. The only thing more brilliant than the sparkle and shine of the beautifully made diamond is the sparkle in my fiancée’s eyes as she admires it. I had a wonderful overall experience and would recommend With Clarity to anyone looking to purchase gorgeous, well made jewelry at a fair and reasonable price. Thank you, With Clarity, for making our engagement even more special.
My husband bought me the engagement ring and I bought his wedding band from WC. The rings are absolutely stunning and good prices! My engagement ring looks prettier than in the picture. I’ve got a lot of compliments from that. Also, there is some lack of information updating from the website which they didn’t do a good job about the time processing. I got the ring three-four months ago right now but my order still said ”being process”.
Buying online from With Clarity helped me get a great ring at what I think is the best possible price. The transaction was smooth, the paperwork is all in order, and the product is beautiful. Highly recommended.
Honestly amazed how much was saved by purchasing an engagement ring through WithClarity. I visited several jewelers in NY & PA and noting was even close to comparable with similar grades from GIA. Couldn't recommend enough.
Efficient shopping experience, amazing prices, beautiful diamond and setting. The ring arrived promptly in packaging the showed extreme attention to detail. We had to resize the ring after I proposed and it was a quick, painless process (We only paid for shipping).
The ring was perfect, she loves it. I was skeptical about buying a ring online because it's a large purchase, but I saved a lot of money compared to going to the store. Also, they have a huge selection of diamonds and knowledgeable customer service to talk when I had questions. It took a few weeks to get the ring as quoted and the ring came with GIA cert. Overall I'm happy with my purchase and would buy from with clarity again.
Beautiful diamond ring with everything orchestrated smoothly from ordering to receiving. Easy to talk with someone if you have questions.
I bought my diamond from here then had it set at a local place. I was a little worried about purchasing online, but the diamond was mailed quickly, in sturdy packaging, and I had to sign for it. The diamond itself was absolutely breathtaking. The jeweler himself said it was beautiful and matched the description on the certification. Overall, it was an easy experience and I am beyond happy with my purchase.
Wife absolutely loves the ring! Came as described and has an amazing sparkle. I have received nothing but positive feedback about the ring. The infinity twist setting was definitely worth it the price. Will definitely do business with them in the future.
Compared all the major online retailers and With Clarity provided the best value and supplied IGI Certification documents with the order. Diamond is so bright it shines in every situation.
Solitaire engagement ring was perfect. My fiancé hates her custom wedding band. We customized the wedding band by adding diamonds to it. The CAD rendering does not offer a fair picture of what you’ll receive and now there’s nothing we can do. With Clarity was unwilling to even allow us to send it back for a credit on a different, more expensive band. Now I’m going to have to sell it for a fraction of the price to make sure my fiancé likes her ring.
I understand a no refund policy on a custom ring, but to not even allow some wiggle room on a return and upgrade is unacceptable in my opinion. Especially when they made the ring and know the value.
The cost savings on the diamond and solitaire setting is worth it to use this company however I highly recommend avoiding custom purchases and physically going into your local jeweler to review options.
Made the buying process incredibly easy and seamless. Amazing and attentive staff to help you through and questions or concerns that come up along the way. Highly recommend!!!
Great company and prices! I see it as a cool startup disrupting the jewelry industry.
Great designs, great stones, and great prices! A perfect choice
Honestly, an amazing spot to purchase a ring from. I was purchasing it in the midst of COVID shutdowns, so I didn't have an opportunity to go to a store. But the quality and prices are amazing, and getting a free resize is a huge bonus
Best jewelry buying process I have ever been through. Found the perfect solitaire for half off most retail stores in my area. Will definitely be back for all my other purchases in the future.
The website was really easy to use. Customer service was great to work with too. When I emailed them about tentative date of delivery they replied within an hour. Awesome experience.
Best decision using this company. Great price for an amazing ring. Alot cheaper than diamond stores for exact same ring on here.
They had an excellent selection at great prices. The ring was delivered on time as per their schedule and my fiancé loved the ring!
Loved their wide selection and unbeatable prices! Got a pavé setting ring for the misses and she absolutely loved it! Highly recommended!
For almost all of my diamond needs I go to With Clarity. I have bought around 8 or 9 loose diamonds since July 2020. I bought 6 from them.
Before you buy a diamond or 2, check with Clarity website first...
Great quality for a lab diamond. Came safely and in a timely manner!
I searched everywhere for the right deal and the right stone. After looking at literally hundreds of stones in with clarity, I found a beautiful VVS2 F color diamond that my fiancée now stares at daily. While I won’t be needing an engagement ring again, I wouldn’t hesitate to order a diamond through with clarity again ever! My experience was fantastic. Diamond was graded, sent impeccably and the communication with the vendor was better than expected. This review almost sounds fake but it really isn’t lol. Truly grateful that I found the site.
Awesome support was able to accommodate an set to include diamonds on matching band.
Excellent diamond plus ring combination with great customer service.
Loved the simplicity and price!! Will absolutely recommend to others!
Easy to filter diamonds I was looking for, I had my diamond shipped to a local jeweler in order to have a wider selection and customize the ring I wanted the diamond set in. I contacted the service team prior to ordering and they assured me the diamond I wanted was kept in their internal stock. There were no issues with shipping, it shipped faster than I expected and reached my jeweler safely. The product was well packaged with the official certification papers inside.
With Clarity gave me the confidence to buy a diamond and setting online. The gemologists helped me to understand the choices. When the setting I wanted wasn't available, With Clarity talked to a vendor to customize the setting for me.
Fantastic site. They got me a diamond I could only have dreamed about by a price nobody could beat!
Overall great experience, Great ring for a great price. You can't beat the try on at home feature either, receiving the real rings makes it look that much better!
Got such an amazing deal on a diamond ring my now fiancee was thrilled with through With Clarity. Delivery was fast and on time (even a little early in the midst of a pandemic), engraving was spot on, and sizing was perfect. Would highly recommend.
Fabulous company, extremely forthright and transparent. They were super helpful I’m finding the perfect diamond and the quality was as would have expected from any local jewelry store, probably better. I would definitely recommend this company to anyone I know.
Contact
46-24 28th street, Long Island City, NY
Wedding vendors in Long Island City
With Clarity's photos